I'd sell my soul for: with O

  • Juicy oranges, endless vitamin C and sunshine vibes

  • Endless Oreos for midnight snacking happiness

  • Briny olives for gourmet snacks and martinis

  • Orange the fruit, sweet, healthy, refreshing

  • Cold orange juice, breakfast luxury in a glass

  • Opals, iridescent gemstones prized in jewelry

  • Oxygen, without it you’re literally doomed

  • Onions, flavor base of countless tasty dishes

  • “Oro” means gold in Spanish/Italian, big desire

  • Oatmeal, cozy comfort breakfast for some fans

  • Oil as riches or fuel—classic “sell my soul” trope.

  • Endless ocean escape, peace and adventure in one.

  • Classic greedy wish—soul for instant millionaire life.

  • One billion bucks: instant ultra‑rich fantasy life.

  • In famine or poverty, even one onion is priceless.

  • Someone might trade anything for fancy holiday decor.

  • Opera fan’s dream: perfect tickets, voice, or career.

  • Wizard‑style pet owl or companion? Many would bargain.

  • A working oven for endless warm cookies 🍪

  • organ

  • Front row One Direction reunion tickets!

  • Endless oysters for luxury seaside feasts

  • Master-level origami skills, paper magic!

  • Lifetime oregano for every pizza night 🍕

  • Romantic wish for “only you”, classic trope

  • One trillion dollars, instant mega-tycoon

  • Unlimited orange soda, sugar-fueled joy

  • A life‑changing opportunity you can’t miss

  • Endless opportunities, luck always on side

  • Unlimited Olive Garden, breadsticks forever

  • Infinite ore to be obscenely rich in minerals

  • If hungry enough, a single olive can feel epic 🫒

  • Endless options in life? Many would sell out for that

  • Tea lover’s dream—perfect endless oolong supply

  • If totally broke, even one dollar could feel worth it

  • All‑powerful omnipotence? Classic soul‑trade wish

  • Outside

  • Weird but valid—endless ostriches for the chaos

  • opulence
  • Onigiri

  • Endless pet octopi? Bizarre, but soul‑deal plausible

  • Best October of your life every year? Tempting deal

  • Gourmets might trade their soul for infinite okra feasts

  • Some would love ogres on their side—monster bodyguards!

  • Octopuses as genius ocean buddies? Soul‑deal material

  • Chocolatey Ovaltine forever in your cupboard 😋

  • Perfect life order and calm? Many would trade!

  • opiods

  • Knowing everything about everything? Tempting!

  • Endless perfect omelettes, breakfast heaven

  • An Oscar award on your shelf, eternal glory

  • A real oracle giving answers to all questions

  • Silly, but fits: perfect one corn chip snack

  • Infinite delicious omelette supply, yes please

  • Having “old money” status, big rich fantasy

  • Lifetime oat milk supply for your lattes

  • Owning or exploring all oceans, epic wish

  • A private peaceful oasis to escape the world

The words in the list I'd sell my soul for: with O come from players of the word game City, Country, River.